What bothers most about Anduin kidnapping is not how hamfisted and out of the blue it happened with 2 random guys yoinking the alliance leader in the middle of the day.
If Anduin could so easily be removed why haven't it happened before? Where were his security? Why not end all wars by just yanking the current enemy faction leader? Basically, this is the kind of stupid move which makes you look hard at your game and you start to notice ALL ridiculous things which you usually ignore like Warlocks walking with demons at broad daylight or the use of ships for transport when you have permanent portals working 24/7.
Sometimes I want to go back to WoW to see how the story is developing but than I see this and think "nah brah, don't bother".